The game belonged to the ninth inning until Toronto made the 10th their own. The Blue Jays scored three times in extra innings to defeat Milwaukee 9-7, erasing what had been a dramatic comeback by the Brewers just moments earlier.
Jake Bauers carried Milwaukee's early offense with a three-run homer in the fourth inning that gave the Brewers a 3-0 lead. Bauers finished 1-for-4 with three RBIs and a walk, his fifth home run lifting his season average to .240 with 13 RBIs.
The ninth inning brought chaos to American Family Field. Toronto took control with three runs, as Okamoto singled to left to score Straw, Giménez grounded out to second to bring home Schneider, and Clement singled to left to drive in Okamoto. Milwaukee answered immediately in the bottom half, as Turang singled to left to score Frelick, then Lockridge doubled to left to bring home Turang and send Bauers to third, tying the game 6-6.
The 10th inning broke open for Toronto. Guerrero Jr. doubled to left to score Clement, then Straw doubled to left to bring home both Sánchez and Guerrero Jr., extending the lead to 6-9. Grant Anderson took the loss for Milwaukee, allowing three runs in one inning of work. Louie Varland earned the win for Toronto with 1.1 innings of relief.
Milwaukee fell to 8-7 and extended their losing streak to five games. Toronto improved to 6-9 despite their own two-game skid. Vladimir Guerrero is nine games away from 1,000 career games, while Kevin Gausman sits 15 strikeouts from 2,000 career strikeouts with a 2.82 ERA.